Venice Cup
Match of the Day Great Britain v USA 1


Friday morning saw the vugraph show visit the Venice Cup for the first team. The match featured fourth-placed USA1, the champions of the United States, and seventh-placed Great Britain, the champions of Europe.

First blood went to the Americans, though the swing could easily have gone the other way.

Board 1. Dealer North. Love All
spade 9 8
heart A Q 10 2
diamond 7 6 4 2
club J 10 9
spade A K 10 2 spade 6 5 4 3
heart J 8 6 5 heart 9 3
diamond Q 9 diamond 10 8 3
club K Q 7 club 8 6 5 3
spade Q J 7
heart K 7 4
diamond A K J 5
club A 4 2

It seemed that the Americans were fated to lose on the board when Letizia/Berkowitz stayed out of game. They bid: 1club - 1diamond - 1NT - 2club - 2diamond - 2NT - Pass. Pat Davies led three rounds of spades and Marinesa Letizia played diamonds from the top and claimed nine tricks; +150.

In the other room Heather Dhondy opened 1diamond, either five cards or, if only four, then 17+ balanced. Tobi Sokolow doubled and Liz McGowan bid 2heart, showing a raise to 3diamond with a reasonable heart suit. Perhaps Dhondy should be able to bid a forcing 2NT now to check back for a 5-3 heart fit, but she just raised to 4heart, probably assuming that McGowan would hold five of them.

4heart was not without play but it would take some good guessing. The lead was a spade to the queen and king and Sokolow switched to the clubK. McGowan won the ace and played heartQ, heart2 to the king, and a heart to the ten. So far so good, but now she finessed the diamondJ and was one down; -50 and 5 IMPs to USA1.

Board 4. Dealer West. Game All
spade Q J
heart K 10 7 6
diamond 4 2
club J 10 9 6 4
spade 10 4 2 spade 9
heart A 4 heart J 9 8 3 2
diamond J 10 9 8 7 6 3 diamond Q 5
club 3 club K Q 8 5 2
spade A K 8 7 6 5 3
heart Q 5
diamond A K
club A 7

This was one of the more entertaining boards of the round. In the Closed Room, Letizia opened a strong club in fourth seat and when Davies' 2diamond weak jump overcall came back to her jumped to 4spade, where she scored +650.

In the Open Room, Sokolow opened 2spade as dealer, showing a bad pre-empt in any suit. Mildred Breed guessed that her partner's suit might well be spades and passed this, leaving Dhondy with an interesting decision on the South cards. She decided that the best thing at the prevailing vulnerability was to pass, and collect a lot of hundreds. This would only be seriously wrong if her side had a slam.

McGowan led the clubJ to the king and ace. Dhondy cashed the spadeA and McGowan followed with the jack. That must be wrong as it is consistent with spadeJ10x, whereas the play of the queen would leave Dhondy with nothing to lose by underleading her king on the next round. Sure enough, Dhondy continued with the spadeK, giving declarer a trump trick. She continued by cashing her two diamond winners then led a third spade. Declarer won and played a diamond and Dhondy ruffed and switched to the heart5. Sokolow rose with the ace and needed to play a second heart to break up the impending squeeze. But she played another diamond and Dhondy ruffed and started to run the trumps. Alas, McGowan had not spotted the squeeze against dummy and bared her heartK so dummy made a club at the end for five down; -500 but 4 IMPs to USA1.

Board 6. Dealer West. E/W Game
spade A J 10 8 6
heart K 8 7
diamond 7
club 10 9 6 3
spade K spade Q 9
heart A Q J 4 3 2 heart 5
diamond 9 2 diamond A Q J 10 6 5 4 3
club Q 8 7 5 club A K
spade 7 5 4 3 2
heart 10 9 6
diamond K 8
club J 4 2

A very difficult constructive bidding problem for East/West but the British pair had the methods to cope with the main issues.

Closed Room
West North East South
Davies Berkowitz Smith Letizia

2diamond Pass
2spade Pass 3diamond Pass
3heart Pass 4diamond Pass
4spade Pass 4NT Pass
5diamond All Pass

2diamond was a multi, weak in a major, strong in a minor or strong and balanced. 2spade showed interest opposite hearts but not spades and 3diamond showed 8/9 playing tricks with diamonds. Davies showed her hearts but when Nicola Smith could only repeat her diamonds Davies cuebid the spade control. Smith checked on key cards and found two were missing so settled for 5diamond.

Open Room
West North East South
Sokolow McGowan Breed Dhondy

1diamond Pass
1heart Pass 3club Pass
3heart Pass 3spade Pass
6club Pass 6diamond All Pass

The American methods were not so well suited to the problem. Breed had to open at the one-level but had no attractive rebid. She invented a club suit then used fourth suit forcing and now Sokolow jumped to 6club, having no reason to imagine that her partner didn't have genuine clubs. Breed converted to 6diamond, of course, but with the diamondK offside that had to fail, giving 12 IMPs to Great Britain. A random swing, dependent on a finesse, but you would prefer to be able to have the British auction.

Board 8. Dealer West. Love All
spade 7 6
heart 7 6 4
diamond Q J 5
club A K 10 5 2
spade 10 2 spade 9 5 3
heart J 9 heart A K Q 10 5 2
diamond A 10 7 6 4 2 diamond K 9 3
club J 6 4 club 3
spade A K Q J 8 4
heart 8 3
diamond 8
club Q 9 8 7

This one was made easy by the American methods in the Closed Room. Lisa Berkowitz opened a mini-no trump on the North cards and Smith overcalled 2heart. Letizia bid 4heart, transfer, and Berkowitz converted to 4spade. The defence took their tricks; +420.

Open Room
West North East South
Sokolow McGowan Breed Dhondy

Pass Pass 1heart 1spade
Dble Pass 2heart 2spade
Pass Pass 3heart Pass
Pass 3spade All Pass

In this room McGowan did not have an opening bid so North/South began with a simple overcall from Dhondy. McGowan might have bid 2club over Sokolow's negative double but you can understand why she passed. But now when Dhondy bid 2spade over 2heart, surely she had shown at least intermediate jump overcall values and McGowan's pass looks a bit wet. Best would be a bid of 3club, showing the main feature of the hand but clearly with spade support given the failure to bid clubs earlier. As it happens, that would have suited Dhondy very well. The defence against 3heart began with three rounds of hearts and Dhondy ruffed high and drew trumps and now the diamond loser went away on the long club; +200 but 6 IMPs to USA1.

Board 11. Dealer South. Love All
spade A 5 3
heart K 6 4 2
diamond J
club A K Q 8 6
spade J 8 7 4 2 spade Q 10
heart 7 5 heart J 10
diamond K 9 7 3 diamond 10 6 5 4 2
club 7 5 club J 4 3 2
spade K 9 6
heart A Q 9 8 3
diamond A Q 8
club 10 9

Closed Room
West North East South
Davies Berkowitz Smith Letizia

1heart
Pass 2NT Pass 3NT
Pass 4spade Pass 5heart
Pass 5spade Pass 6heart
All Pass
Marinessa Letizia (USA1)


2NT was a forcing heart raise and 3NT showed extra values in a balanced hand. 4spade was Kickback, the response showing two key cards plus the trump queen, and 5spade invited seven and asked for kings.

It seems that Letizia might have bid 5NT now to show the spadeK, but perhaps it didn't occur to her.

With a near minimum for her previous bidding she didn't want to bid beyond 6heart and signed-off; +1010.


Open Room
West North East South
Sokolow McGowan Breed Dhondy

1heart
Pass 3club Pass 3heart
Pass 3spade Pass 4diamond
Pass 4NT Pass 5spade
Pass 5NT Pass 6heart
Pass 7heart All Pass

3club was a natural strong jump shift and 3spade agreed hearts. Now 4NT and 5NT were essentially the same as 4spade and 5spade at the other table. Dhondy did not even have the luxury of knowing she was facing four-card heart support and it is perhaps not surprising that she chose to sign-off in 6heart after a little thought. But McGowan had been thinking and realised that, while she couldn't be certain of 13 tricks, she might have bid seven on the previous round. She did so now, and that was 11 IMPs to Great Britain.

There is a lesson to be learned from this deal. Suppose that the Americans had appealed against the 7heart bid, given that North had taken control and received a negative response from partner but only after some thought. It is quite possible that the 7heart bid would be cancelled by an appeals committee. All credit to Sokolow and Breed for accepting the result in good spirit. The moral is not to make bids like 5NT without thinking because sometimes partner's tempo may remove some of your options on the next round.

Board 12. Dealer West. N/S Game
spade K 9 8 7 3
heart A 8 7 5 2
diamond 6
club J 4
spade 10 2 spade 6 5 4
heart Q heart J 10 9 6 3
diamond K Q J 9 8 7 5 diamond 3
club K Q 3 club A 6 5 2
spade A Q J
heart K 4
diamond A 10 4 2
club 10 9 8 7

This was a dull board in the Closed Room and a great result for Smith/Davies. Davies opened 1diamond as dealer and Berkowitz passed. Smith responded 1heart, Davies rebid 2diamond, and that was that. Davies lost two trump tricks so that was +90.

In the Open Room, McGowan cuebid 2diamond, showing both majors, over the opening bid. That silenced Breed and Dhondy jumped to 4spade. That contract can be made but it takes some care and not everybody managed it. Dhondy didn't have to worry about the play because Sokolow saved in 5diamond. Dhondy doubled, of course, and the defence took their top tricks then led a third spade. Sokolow ruffed, crossed to the clubA and played a diamond to her seven; two down for -300 and 9 IMPs to Great Britain.

Board 13. Dealer North. Game All
spade A K J 10 6 4 2
heart 8 3
diamond K J 9 8
club
spade 9 8 7 3 spade
heart 4 2 heart Q J 10 9 7 5
diamond 7 2 diamond A Q 3
club Q 10 6 3 2 club K 8 7 4
spade Q 5
heart A K 6
diamond 10 6 5 4
club A J 9 5

Another close slam decision and again the winning action was to stop in game (actually, this one is significantly worse than the diamond finesse because of entry problems). The Americans dealt with the hand very easily. Berkowitz opened 4diamond, showing a good 4spade bid, Smith overcalled 4heart, and Letizia bid 4spade, ending the auction.

McGowan opened only 1spade and Breed overcalled 2heart. Dhondy made a negative double and McGowan jumped to 4spade. Now Dhondy had a fair bit to spare for her double and made a slam try, cuebidding 5club. McGowan cuebid in turn, 5diamond, and that was all Dhondy needed to bid the slam. Perhaps McGowan might not have made the 'automatic cuebid. She didn't have all that much to spare for her 4spade bid and the 5club bid had hardly improved her hand.

Anyway, justice was done when there were two diamond losers; 13 IMPs to USA1.

Board 16. Dealer West. E/W Game
spade A Q
heart Q 10 5 3 2
diamond 8 7
club A Q 9 7
spade 10 9 2 spade K J 6 5 4
heart A 4 heart J 9 8
diamond Q 5 diamond 10 9 4 2
club K J 10 8 4 2 club 5
spade 8 7 3
heart K 7 6
diamond A K J 6 3
club 6 3

Remember Board 4? Again Sokolow opened with a pre-empt and was allowed to play there while her team-mates were playing game on the opposing cards.

Closed Room
West North East South
Davies Berkowitz Smith Letizia

1club 1heart 1spade 2spade
Pass 1NT Pass 3diamond
Pass 3NT All Pass

The Americans did well to overcome the East/West bidding and reach game. Smith led her singleton club to the ten and queen and Berkowitz led a heart to the king and ace. Davies switched to the spade10 for the queen and king and all Smith had to do was return a spade and down the contract would have gone. But she was not convinced that Davies would have the spade9 and switched to a diamond. Berkowitz went up with the ace and cleared the hearts and eventually dropped the diamondQ to make nine tricks; +400.

On vugraph, Sokolow opened 3club on the West hand, supposedly a sound pre-empt. Should anyone bid over that? Again the vulnerability was no doubt a contributory factor in Dhondy's decision to go quietly. McGowan led a heart against 3club - nine, king and ace. Sokolow returned a heart to the queen and McGowan switched to a diamond. Dhondy won the king and ace of diamonds and continued with the jack. Sokolow ruffed with the eight, over-ruffed with the nine. Now McGowan switched to the spadeA, followed by the queen. Sokolow could see a possible spade ruff coming so threw her third spade on the heartJ before playing a club for the ten and queen. But that heart play was counter-productive because it meant that now McGowan could play a fourth heart and Dhondy could ruff with the six, promoting McGowan's club7 into a trick. That brought the contract up to four down; -400 and an unusual push.

Board 18. Dealer East. N/S Game
spade Q 9 7
heart K 6 5
diamond 10 6 5 2
club 6 5 2
spade A K J 10 4 3 2 spade 8 6 5
heart 7 heart A J 10 4 3
diamond Q 8 7 3 diamond K
club K club A 9 7 3
spade
heart Q 9 8 2
diamond A J 9 4
club Q J 10 8 4

Another close slam hand on which it was right to stay low, but this time the slam is well over 80% so can be considered to be genuinely unlucky. Both our East/West pairs were equally poor in that they stopped in game, but neither will be complaining.

Closed Room
West North East South
Davies Berkowitz Smith Letizia

1heart Pass
1spade Pass 2spade Pass
4club Pass 4heart Pass
4spade All Pass

Smith's immediate spade raise seemed to have put the British pair in some jeopardy but Davies splintered and respected the 4spade sign-off.

Open Room
West North East South
Sokolow McGowan Breed Dhondy

1heart Pass
1spade Pass 2club Pass
4spade All Pass

Breed did not raise spades, preferring to show her second suit. 2club is a wide-range bid and Sokolow might have gone more slowly now, just in case. However, she jumped to 4spade and that was that.

This board produced swings in several matches but in USA1 v Great Britain it was just a dull push.

The match ended in a 41-31 IMP, 17-13 VP win for Great Britain, leaving both teams in the qualifying positions but still with plenty of work to do.

Results Contents
Bermuda Bowl Rounds 13, 14, 15
Venice Cup Rounds 13, 14, 15
Match of the day Gt. Britain v USA 1
Bridge for Peace Press Conference
USA 2 v Norway by Barry Rigal
The trump unblock by Patrick Jourdain



Return to Top of page To Front Page